There was a point on Saturday—halfway through the vote—when lemons bars were one vote ahead. We held out a glimmer of hope for those tangy and creamy cookies, but, as it turns out, old favorites never go stale. We had a growing suspicion that chocolate chip would come out on top; they crushed the competition in practically every vote.
See all the different versions of this cookie that you can make.
Or try creating endless variations by using mix-ins like oats, coconut, and dried cherries.
Even better: Now that warmer weather is approaching, mini chocolate chip ice cream sandwiches would be a satisfying weekend treat.